2723098 Final Rulemaking of Appeal Procedures for Denial of a Petition to Establish a District of Columbia Public Charter School
-
OFFICE OF THE STATE SUPERINTENDENT OF EDUCATION
NOTICE OF FINAL RULEMAKING
The State Superintendent of Education, pursuant to the authority set forth in section 3(b)(11) of the State Education Office Establishment Act of 2000, effective October 21, 2000 (D.C. Law 13-176; D.C. Official Code § 38-2602(b)(11)) (2011 Supp.) and section 2203(j)(2) of the District of Columbia School Reform Act of 1995, approved April 26, 1996 (Pub. L. 104-134; 110 Stat. 1321; D.C. Official Code § 38-1802.03(j)(2)) (2011 Supp.), hereby gives notice of the adoption of a final rule amending chapter 54 (Appeal Procedures for Denial of a Petition to Establish a District of Columbia Public Charter School) of subtitle A (Office of the State Superintendent of Education) of title 5 (Education) of the District of Columbia Municipal Regulations (DCMR) by clarifying and extending the procedures for an Eligible Applicant to appeal to the Office of the State Superintendent of Education (OSSE) from a decision by a District of Columbia Eligible Chartering Authority denying a petition to establish a public charter school in the District of Columbia.
The purpose of the rule is to maintain the regulatory framework of chapter 54 established effective May 22, 2009, published at 56 DCR 4108, and update and clarify the timeline for the submission of the Appeal Record and the Eligible Applicant’s written submission in support of the appeal. The final rulemaking also permits both the Eligible Applicant and the Eligible Chartering Authority to request a Record Review Hearing to review the findings of the Eligible Chartering Authority.
These rules were previously published in the D.C. Register as emergency and proposed rulemaking on April 27, 2012, at 59 DCR 3740. No comments were received from the public in connection with this notice during the thirty (30) day comment period. No changes were requested and no substantive changes have been made. The Department took final rulemaking action on June 25, 2012. These final rules will be effective upon publication of this notice in the D.C. Register.
Chapter 54 (Appeal Procedures for Denial of a Petition to Establish a District of Columbia Public Charter School) of subtitle A (Office of the State Superintendent of Education) of title 5 (Education) of the District of Columbia Municipal Regulations (DCMR) is amended as follows:
Section 5400, GENERAL PROVISIONS, is amended to read as follows:
5400 General Provisions
5400.1 A final written decision issued by an Eligible Chartering Authority denying a Petition to establish a public charter school in the District of Columbia is subject to review by an appropriate court of the District of Columbia or the State Superintendent of Education.
5400.2 These rules set forth procedures for an appeal to the State Superintendent of Education.
Section 5401, FILING AND NOTIFICATION REQUIREMENTS, is amended to read as follows:
5401 Filing and Notification Requirements
5401.1 An Eligible Applicant may appeal the Eligible Chartering Authority’s final written decision to the State Superintendent of Education no later than fifteen (15) business days after the date of the Eligible Chartering Authority’s decision.
5401.2 The notice of appeal shall contain the following information:
(a) The name of the Eligible Applicant including the name, signature, address, and telephone number of the Eligible Applicant’s representative, and other relevant contact information;
(b) The name of the Eligible Chartering Authority; and
(c) The effective date of the Eligible Chartering Authority’s final written decision denying a Petition.
5401.3 The Office of the State Superintendent of Education (OSSE) shall assign a case number to each appeal and provide written confirmation of receipt of the appeal to the Eligible Applicant and the Eligible Chartering Authority.
5401.4 A notice of appeal filed later than fifteen (15) business days after the date of the Eligible Chartering Authority’s final written decision denying a Petition shall be deemed out of time and shall be rejected by the OSSE with written notification to the Eligible Applicant and the Eligible Chartering Authority.
5401.5 An Eligible Applicant’s notice of appeal, the record, and all submissions related to an appeal shall be delivered to the OSSE, Attention: Office of the General Counsel, Charter School Petition Appeals, at the OSSE’s main address.
5401.6 All documents filed with regard to an appeal under this chapter shall
include a Certificate of Service, signed by the authorized representative of the party filing a document.
5401.7 The Certificate of Service must state the following:
(a) The date and the method of service (for example, mail or hand delivery); and
(b) The names and addresses of the persons served in accordance with
this chapter.
5401.8 When documents are mailed, three (3) business days shall be added to the
mailing date for purposes of calculating time within this chapter.
Section 5402, APPEAL RECORD, is amended to read as followed:
5402 Appeal Record
5402.1 No later than ten (10) business days after the date of a notice of an appeal, the Eligible Chartering Authority shall deliver to the OSSE and to the Eligible Applicant a copy of the final written decision denying the Petition and the record related to the Petition.
5402.2 The record shall consist of all documents relevant to the Petition and the Eligible Chartering Authority’s final written decision denying the Petition including without limitation:
(a) The Petition to establish a public charter school, including all exhibits to the Petition;
(b) The transcript of any public hearings or testimony before the Eligible Chartering Authority with regard to the Petition subject to appeal, including all exhibits referenced in the transcript;
(c) All other materials related to the Petition submitted by the Eligible Applicant to the Eligible Charting Authority; and
(d) The final written decision of the Eligible Chartering Authority
Section 5403, WRITTEN SUBMISSIONS, is amended to read as followed:
5403 Written Submissions
5403.1 No later than fifteen (15) business days after the date that the Eligible Chartering Authority delivers the Appeal Record referred to in § 5402, the Eligible Applicant shall submit to the OSSE a double spaced written submission in support of the appeal.
5403.2 The Eligible Chartering Authority shall respond no later than fifteen (15) business days after the date of the Eligible Applicant’s submission referred to in § 5403.1, with a double spaced written response to matters that the Eligible Applicant raised.
5403.3 Written submissions shall set forth precise statements in support of the position being taken on appeal with regard to challenging or supporting the Eligible Chartering Authority’s written decision including, as appropriate:
(a) Specific reasons and basis for disagreeing with the Eligible Chartering Authority’s final written decision; and
(b) How the Eligible Chartering Authority’s written decision should be altered or reversed, based upon specific facts in the record supporting the written submission on appeal including any pertinent legal authority; or
(c) Specific reasons and basis in the record to confirm the Eligible
Chartering Authority’s final written decision.
5403.4 An Eligible Applicant’s failure to make a timely written submission to the State Superintendent under this chapter shall constitute an automatic withdrawal of the notice of appeal.
5403.5 The OSSE shall notify the parties in writing when an appeal is deemed to have been withdrawn, with no further involvement of the OSSE with regard to the appeal.
Section 5404, FINAL DECISION, is repealed and replaced with:
5404 Record Review Hearing
5404.1 The Eligible Chartering Authority and the Eligible Applicant shall both have the option to request a Record Review Hearing to review the findings of the Eligible Chartering Authority before the OSSE, no later than five (5) business days after the filing of the Eligible Chartering Authority’s written submission referred to in § 5403.2.
5404.2 The Eligible Chartering Authority and the Eligible Applicant shall request a hearing through a written submission to the OSSE. A request filed later than five (5) business days after the filing of the Eligible Chartering Authority’s written submission shall be deemed untimely and shall not be considered by the OSSE.
5404.3 If a Record Review Hearing is requested by the Eligible Chartering Authority or the Eligible Applicant, the OSSE shall, no later than ten (10) business days after receipt of the request, schedule a Record Review Hearing and notify the Eligible Chartering Authority and the Eligible Applicant of the Record Review Hearing Date.
5404.4 The Record Review Hearing shall consider only evidence in the record. New evidence shall not be introduced at the hearing.
Section 5405, FINAL DECISION, is added to read:
5405 Final Decision
5405.1 The State Superintendent’s review shall be limited to the record, record review hearing, and written submissions of the Eligible Chartering Authority and the Eligible Applicant.
5405.2 The State Superintendent shall uphold the Eligible Chartering Authority’s decision if it is based on Substantial Evidence in the record.
5405.3 The State Superintendent’s final written decision shall affirm, reverse in whole, or remand for further consideration the Eligible Chartering Authority’s decision.
5405.4 If the State Superintendent reverses the Eligible Chartering Authority’s decision and grants a Petition, the State Superintendent’s decision shall instruct the Eligible Chartering Authority to grant the Petition no later than fifteen (15) business days afterthe date of the State Superintendent’s final written decision.
5405.5 The State Superintendent shall provide both parties with a copy of his or her final written decision.
Section 5499, DEFINITIONS, is amended to read as follows:
5499 Definitions
5499.1 The following terms and phrases shall have the meanings ascribed:
Certificate of Service means a signed written statement indicating that documents filed with or issued by the OSSE have been either delivered or mailed to the other appropriate parties.
Eligible Applicant means a person, including a private public or quasi public entity, or an institution of higher education as defined in § 1201(a) of the Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. § 1141(a)), that seeks to establish a public charter school in the District of Columbia pursuant to the District of Columbia School Reform Act of 1995, approved April 26, 1996 (110 Stat.1321-107, Pub. L. 104-134; D.C. Official Code § 38-1802.02, et seq. (2001 & 2011 Supp.)(as amended)).
Eligible Chartering Authority means the District of Columbia Public Charter School Board or any entity authorized as an eligible chartering authority in the District of Columbia.
OSSE means the Office of the State Superintendent of Education.
Petition means a written application by an Eligible Applicant to establish a public charter school in the District of Columbia.
Record Review Hearing means an optional hearing before the State Superintendent or the State Superintendent’s designee requested by an Eligible Chartering Authority or Eligible Applicant during which the previous record in an appeal is reviewed and clarified by the parties.
State Superintendent means the State Superintendent of Education and may include the State Superintendent’s designee.
Substantial Evidence means such relevant evidence as a reasonable person might accept as adequate to support a conclusion or finding.
